Phonar: Task 5 – Final Images + Critical Rationale

For steps 4 and 5 of task 5 I had to complete the assignment in the Photographer’s Playbook by Massimo Vitali and provide a rationale for my decisions. The task called for me to make intentional mistakes while shooting a roll of film and these mistakes could lead to an unintentional masterpiece of an image. Below are my final images and critical rationale.

r001-016

r001-023

r001-021

r001-017

r001-015

CNV00007

CNV00021

r001-013

r001-007

r001-027

r001-022

r001-020

r001-018

r001-014

r001-008

r001-006

r001-001

Critical Rationale

After reading the assignment many times and trying to work out how I wanted to intentionally make mistakes I decided to use a disposable camera as in the past when I have taken images on a disposable it is very unpredictable what the outcome will be even if I use the correct lighting and keep the camera still. I wanted to play with the unpredictability of outcome of the images even further by intentionally taking images while walking, photographing from angles that would not be in focus, pointing the camera into the shade and direct sunlight, moving the camera while holding the shutter and even using the camera without flash in dark lighting conditions outdoors. After carrying out research into Massimo Vitali for my other steps and discovering he shot in the direct sun on a summers day I wanted to include this element into my own work by shooting directly into the sun. This is something I often avoid due to the sun causing glare or harsh shadows however no matter how hard I tried to distort the image or cause a mistake that would result in the image looking bad once getting the images developed it was evident that my attempts to ruin the image actually created an abstract element to the image and don’t necessarily make the image bad. In fact it makes the images look almost documentary like almost like images taken by a participant. This is something I would like to continue to experiment with in my own work in the future and I now have the confidence to make mistakes while shooting as they could turn out to be an interesting and unusual image.

154MC: The Teacher’s Diary Film Review

The-Teachers-Diary-2014

The Teacher’s Diary is a heartfelt romantic comedy that was directed and written by Nithiwat Tharathorn, a director what is well known within the Thai film industry, particularly for this solo debut film Seasons Change. With a growing list of successful romantic comedy films, The Teacher’s Diary further is set to contribute to this legacy. The two characters lives break the typical romantic comedy motif of boy meets girl, fall in love only to break up and get back together at the end. A change that was very refreshing to watch. The two characters lives run parallel with one another and take a similar turn of events as they face the same difficulties as one another. However they never meet until the end. The eagerly anticipated meeting of the characters is one of the aspects that draws the audience in and leaves them wanting more and wanting to know if Ann and Song ever meet.

After being fired from her job at a school, Ann is given a second chance to move to a remote island and teach on a boathouse. Song, a PE teacher is confronted with a similar opportunity to teach on the island for one year. Tired of their old lives and looking for a change, Song and Ann both gave up everything they had to teach children on the remote boathouse. The island was devoid of all aspects of modern life and this proved particularly difficult for both characters, even Ann who is a very strong willed. With an ever-encroaching feeling of loneliness and isolation as well as the struggle of maintaining a long distance relationship, Ann turned to her diary as a place to vent her frustrations and experiences. With the feeling of hopelessness Song was close to leaving the island completely when the discovery of Ann’s illustrated journal changes is perception. Song begins to read the journal and he is able to relate to everything Ann has written, thus it changes his outlook of the situation. He admires Ann’s determination and dedication and in turn he begins to put more effort into the teaching and forms close relationships with the children. Not only does this help develop Song’s character it shows just how important the quality of education is and it serves as a metaphor for never giving up.

The continuous anti-climax of their failed meetings finally ceases at the end of the film, a point where the whole audience let out a sigh of relief. The two leading actors create realistic and loveable characters that the audience can relate to. Although the dialogue was tightly scripted there was no shortage of laughable moments. These moments ensured the film remained light-hearted and never too melancholy. Furthermore the setting of the film provided a cinematic view of the remote island and captured the essence of the film perfectly. The moody mornings to the faded golden light in the evening created a pathetic fallacy, an aspect that made the cinematography work extremely well.

154MC: A Record of Sweet Murder Film Review

A Record of Sweet Murder is a lurid psychodrama and mockumentary film by controversial Japanese director Koji Shiraishi. This is a director whose name many western audiences may only recognise due to the controversy of his earlier film ‘Grotesque’. The film failed to be classified by the BBFC due to the harrowing and graphic depictions of sexual violence. Continuing within this horror sub-genre, Shiraishi creates a found footage style film that consists of one continuous 86-minuet take. The long take draws on parallels in Hitchcock’s films, as well as other found footage horror films such as The Blair Witch Project and Paranormal Activity. As the audience we are able to get an exclusive view of what would be an unseen situation.

The film begins with what appears to be an opportunity for an exclusive interview with an old friend. However, in true thriller style, it ends up being a life threatening and nauseating experience for journalist Soyeon. Childhood friend Sangjoon, who has recently escaped from a mental institution, has contacted Soyeon. Over the phone he explains that he has murdered 18 people and promises to reveal everything to her in an exclusive interview. However he wants the interview to be recorded and with one strict condition; the cameraman has to be Japanese. The recording aims to prove that he isn’t delusional, yet this very candid manner of documenting the event only highlights to the audience the extreme and cold-blooded nature of his actions.

The setting for the interview is a grimy apartment in a run down neighbourhood in Seoul. After arriving in the dilapidated apartment, Soyeon is confronted by a frantic and knife wielding Sangjoon. Immediately it is made clear that Sangjoon is not content with his previous murders. The audience begins to wonder why he is not content and why he has committed these abhorrent crimes, this understanding of why is what underpins the entirety of the film. Sangjoon wants to find salvation through pure love, this deep-rooted obsession started after the death of his childhood friend. Hysterically he tells Soyeon that a higher force has told him that in order to find this sacred pure love he must subject innocent people to violence and even death in order to prove that pure love exists.

The intensity of the situation progresses throughout the film and as a viewer you are left feeling increasingly uncomfortable with the violence and morals behind Sangjoon’s actions. The shaking camera adds to the panic and hysteria, yet at some points the camera remains still. The cameraman appears to have become almost calm and unfased by the brutal realities in front of him. This inconsistency in filming is easily noticeable to the audience due to the one take approach.

While Record may make western audiences feel uncomfortable it still stands as a mellow and toned down version of this popular sub-genre within Japanese films. Due to this, I believe that we will not see films like Record in UK cinemas any time soon.